For as long as he can remember, John E. Keefe Jr. has been surrounded by lawyers.
The son of a judge, attorneys were part of the fabric of his upbringing years before
he joined the profession.
“I fundamentally like lawyers. I find them funny, interesting people,” he said. “My
dad’s friends were some of the most engaging people I had ever met.”
It is fitting, therefore, that this week, Keefe will take on leadership of the New
Jersey State Bar Association, the state’s largest professional organization for attorneys.
Keefe is to be sworn in during an installation ceremony held Thursday night during
the NJSBA Annual Meeting and Convention in Atlantic City. The installation for new
bar leadership will be, for the first time, open to all attendees.
“That notion of openness is really what I want to promote in this coming year,” Keefe
said. “It’s reflective of who we are as a bar and who we are as a society. It’s not
cronyism. This bar is for everyone.”
That openness is also reflective of who Keefe is, both personally and professionally,
friends and family say.
“He’s always been a very affable person, since the time he was a kid,” said John Keefe
Sr., a retired Appellate Division judge. He remembered his son running for president
of his class in high school. “He won it because he gathered in groups that were outside
the mainstream in his class. He brought them into the fold.”
Keefe, a civil trial attorney, is the founder of Keefe Law Firm with offices in Red
Bank, New Brunswick and Newark and Point Pleasant. He leads the firm's plaintiffs' personal
injury, mass tort litigation and complex litigation department.
“The thing that I love the most about the practice of law is I get to represent people
from all walks of life,” he said. “The power of law can equal the playing field amongst
everyone in society.”
PATH TO THE PROFESSION
He didn’t always see law in his professional future. “I wanted to teach English and
history and coach baseball,” he said. But as he grew older, a career in the law became
That was not because of anything his father did directly. In fact, the judge worked
so hard to not put pressure on his son to become a lawyer that at one point, Keefe wondered whether
his dad thought he should enter the profession at all. It was an unnecessary concern.
When Keefe announced he wanted to go to law school, his father was thrilled and confident
that he would be successful.
“I was never told to be a lawyer…but all the ingredients were there,” Keefe said.
“I felt that being a lawyer got my competitive juices going. It was me competing,
most importantly, for something other than myself.”
He made involvement in the organized bar a priority from early on in his career, attending
local county bar dinners and becoming active in state bar association committees.
Along the way, he accumulated his own group of close lawyer friends. Among them is
his friend for over 30 years, Thomas Scrivo, partner at O’Toole, Scrivo, Fernandez,
Weiner, Van Lieu, who is former chief counsel to the governor.
“He’s someone I rely on for advice for counseling for the law, about life, about family…just
about anything,” Scrivo said. “He does not take himself too seriously. He always laughs
in every conversation, even in the toughest times.”
One of those particularly tough times unfolded last year, when Keefe learned he had
Keefe’s wife, Estee, and his three sons were crucial to him getting through that difficult
year. He was lucky, he said, to have had an incredible support system – his father
took over logistics at the firm, his colleagues, employees and friends stepped forward.
And his many lawyer friends were also indispensable, driving him to and from the hospital,
and sitting with him during long sessions of treatment.
LAWYERS HELPING LAWYERS
The experience, he says, inspired one of his initiatives for his year as bar president
– creating a safety net for solo and small-firm practitioners who make up the bulk
of New Jersey’s private lawyers and who are especially vulnerable if their professional
careers are abruptly interrupted by unexpected events.
“Lawyers need to help lawyers,” Keefe said. “What happens when a lawyer gets sick?
What happens when a lawyer, at a small law firm, or a solo practitioner, has a heart
attack? Or gets a diagnosis that means they have to be out of work? What happens to
the law firm? What happens to the clients? What happens to the employees? What happens
to the families?”
That’s why he is working with the bar association to come up with a system that would
allow the practices to continue to function in these times of trauma. A plan that
lawyers could mobilize quickly to help colleagues.
The idea fits squarely with many of Keefe’s goals for his year as NJSBA president,
which fall under the overarching theme of “lawyers helping lawyers.”
“Our constituency is lawyers. The state bar is here to serve the lawyers that make
up our bar.”
Keefe is particularly interested, he said, in addressing the needs of new lawyers,
who are the future of the profession. To that end, another priority of his year as
president will be establishing a formal mentorship program that will connect attorneys
new to the profession, or those who are in a state of transition, with more experienced
attorneys who can guide them.
“I am extremely grateful for the mentors I’ve had in my career. I’ve been lucky. I
hope that we as a state bar can provide mentorship for the newer lawyers through a
real program that can match them with areas of practice and practitioners that they
may not otherwise be exposed to,” Keefe said.
He is also dedicated to following through on two issues that the NJSBA has been advocating
for some time: professional malpractice fairness and diversity initiatives.
“How do we approach diversity? We have to say what we mean, and mean what we say,”
Keefe said. “I think we need to be inclusive of all ideas, and we need to really start
listening to each other, and start making concrete differences.”
Professional malpractice fairness has been a major policy issue for the NJSBA, which
supports legislation that would stabilize the cost of doing business for lawyers and
other licensed professional by bringing the statute of limitations for filing a malpractice
claim to two years, in line with doctors and other professionals in New Jersey and
with lawyers in New York and Pennsylvania. “We need to level the playing field for
lawyers,” Keefe said.
A PROBLEM SOLVER
Keefe’s friends say he’ll make an excellent bar president because he is a problem
solver who genuinely cares about the challenges other people face.
“I think he’ll do a really good job because he wants to do good things for people,”
his father said.
For Keefe, the coming term has special significance in light of what he and his family
have been through in the last several months.
“I think ‘service’ takes on a different meaning this year,” he said. “I look at it
as even more important, as a payback – or a pay forward – for all the good things
that have happened to me and all the people that have helped me.”